Not that I do much with it, but I’m mostly blogging over at Livejournal these days.
Over thataway, folks….
September 15, 2008Perhaps getting less deserted….
June 20, 2018LiveJournal has apparently become seriously compromised by Russia. This inconveniences me minimally, as I’ve made little use of it in the past year. I’ll probably move elsewhere in the long run, but in the interim I’ll dust this off.
Jeff Sessions
June 20, 2018So, over at another WordPress site, someone is claiming it is “false” that
Jeff Sessions said that the separation of church and state was “an extra-constitutional doctrine” and “recent thing that is unhistorical and unconstitutional.”
It traces the quotes as far as this book, but then claims that “there does not appear to be any reference to these quotes” in the source given by the book and that “there does not appear to be any transcript or article on the Internet that supports this claim”. This is an overstatement at best.
Checking via Amazon Preview, it seems the full Edwards reference is to Hans Johnson’s article “Warning: Severe Sessions Ahead”, published in the January 1997 issue of “Church and State” magazine, which is a publication of “Americans United for Separation of Church and State” — a group that is perhaps not exactly unbiased, but technically not atheist. With work, an on-line copy of this article can be found. (At least one other site gives the relevant sections in a partial copy.) They report his phrase there as “extra-constitutional doctrine”, allegedly used in a speech given in May 1996 in Mobile, Alabama. It does not provide additional context by quoting any further extent of the speech. I have not been able to turn up an independent report of that speech.
However, the Johnson article also sources the “recent thing that is unhistorical and unconstitutional” quote as having come from an interview with Sessions in The Alabama Baptist (a weekly publication of the Alabama Baptist Church); no specific date is given, but it is indicated as “later” than the Mobile speech, necessarily must have been before Johnson’s article was published, and (being characterized as part of an election campaign) likely before November. This leaves a window of around 30 issues (mostly or all in volume 161 of the publication) that would need to be searched for definitive proof. The website for The Alabama Baptist does not include any pre-2000 articles, but notes that (Alabama’s) Samford University’s special collections includes an extensive collection of (most?) articles prior to 2000. The Samford University library’s catalog indicates that Volume 161 is in its collection. This could potentially provide independent verification.
Finally, this quote does not appear to be contradicted by any sentiments Sessions has publicly expressed — or at least, none turning up in my quick search for those. It thus appears an overstatement to call the claim “false”, when “unproven” seems more precise — especially as it seems likely provable to ordinary standards of sourcing.
Another Public Catholic complaint
October 14, 2015So, Rebecca Hamilton is again removing comments left at her blog.
Her original piece (on the court-ordered removal of the 10 Commandments Monument from the Oklahoma Capitol) is here (and mirrored in the Wayback machine here.
My now-censored comment was:
For the curious, the rulings in Prescott v OK-CPC by the state supreme court (which quotes the text of the state’s Blaine Amendment) and what appears the federal AA v Thompson final dismissal. I’ll note, the latter case was dismissed on without prejudice on standing grounds; which as a technical point of law means that the federal court did not address whether Representative Kiesel’s position had merit or whether Representative Kiesel’s position was instead wrong.
I’ll also note, Prescott is a Baptist minister. While the SBC tend otherwise these days, the pre-revolutionary history in Virginia leaves some Baptists still quite adamantly against any admixture of Church and State.
Those who aren’t familiar might also care to use Google Scholar to look up the rulings in Van Orden v Perry and McCreary County v ACLU, to see how the Supreme Court distinguishes permissible versus impermissible displays. Aside from its being made of stone, the Oklahoma display seems to more resemble the isolated display in the McCreary case.
The bulk of this comment is purely factual points — albeit ones inconvenient to her presented viewpoint. The last sentence is quite subjective, but would not hardly appear radical enough to qualify as an “attempt to hijack the board with your personal agendas”, or any of the more significant offenses against civility her Blog Rules warn about. Ms. Hamilton appears inclined to respond to dissent via the cognitively lazy approach of selective exposure through censorship, rather than the more effortful approach of counterargument.
Conveniently, the Disqus-based comments allow for me to retrieve my remarks to repost here as protest against this. Petty and probably pointless on my part, but since the censorship can also be termed thus, it might merely be viewed an in-kind response.
Hello world!
September 17, 2006Welcome to WordPress.com. This is your first post. Edit or delete it and start blogging!